Antidepressant Drug
Horrors
"...virtually all of the gun-related massacres that have made headlines over
the past decade have had one thing in common: They were perpetrated by people taking Prozac, Zoloft, Luvox,
Paxil or a related antidepressant drug."
—Dr. Julian Whitaker, M.D.
Following is a
sampling of the hundreds of headline cases of violence, murder and suicide committed by children and adults under
the influence of psychiatric drugs. We put faces to each drug victim so you can see these are
otherwise normal people. They look no different from a neighbor.
November 26, 1987: Bartley James Dobben killed his two young
sons by throwing them into a 1,300-degree foundry ladle. He had been placed on a regimen of
psychiatric drugs in 1985. Mr. Dobben, 28 years old, received the mandatory sentence of life in
prison from Judge James Graves Jr. of Muskegon County Circuit Court.
|
|
|
May 20, 1988: Laurie Dann, age 31; In Winnetka, Illinois; Dann
walked into a second grade classroom carrying three pistols and began shooting innocent little
children. She killed one, wounded six, and then killed herself. Autopsy reports revealed that her
body contained high amounts of Anafranil [by Norvatis] and Lithium.
|
|
|
January 17, 1989: Patrick Purdy, age 25; Purdy opened fire on a
school yard full of young children in Stockton, California. During his vicious and unprovoked
assault, Purdy killed five schoolchildren and wounded thirty others before killing himself. During
the two years prior to the murders of the Stockton children, Purdy had been treated by
psychiatrists who put him on the mind altering drugs Thorazine and Amitriptyline.
|
|
|
April 12, 1989: Abbie Hoffman; At the age of 52, activist and
author, Hoffman committed suicide. He had been taking
Prozac. Hoffman was a social and political activist in the United States, co-founder of the Youth
International Party. He came to prominence in the 1960's, but practiced most of his activism in the
1970's, and has remained a symbol of the youth rebellion of that decade.
|
|
|
September 14, 1989: Louisville, Kentucky: Joseph T.
Wesbecker, 47: One month after he began taking Prozac, Wesbecker shot 20 workers at
Standard Gravure Corp., with an AK-47, killing 9 of them. Wesbecker was included in the fatalities
with a self-inflicted pistol shot to the chin. "The doctor noted that he got agitated and possibly
deluded, and he said 'stop the Prozac', and it was days after that, with the Prozac still in his
system, that he committed these murders and suicide." The Eli Lilly pharmaceutical company,
manufacturers of Prozac, had to contend with the damage suit brought by the survivors of
Wesbecker's murder spree and the families of the dead, who alleged that his action had been caused
by his use of Prozac. The antidepressant drug accounted for about a third of Lilly's
multibillion-dollar sales, and eventually the company settled the case via a payout kept secret
even from the judge.
|
|
|
April of 1996: Kurt Danysh (18); Was prescribed the drug
Prozac (from Eli Lilly) by a general practitioner who failed to perform any psychological testing.
Shortly after beginning to take his Prozac prescription, Kurt, a normally outgoing teenager, became
withdrawn and moody. By the second week, he was restless and violent. He got into a fight with his
best friend and purposely crashed his truck into a stone wall. This was out of character for Kurt.
Seventeen days after his first dose of Prozac, he shot and killed his father by firing a shotgun
blast into his father's head. Kurt had no history of violence prior to Prozac. He was convicted of
murdering his father and sentenced to 22.5 to 60 years in prison. Kurt later said, "I didn't
realize I did it until after it was done, and then I realized it. This might sound weird, but it
felt like I had no control of what I was doing, like I was left there just holding a gun."
|
|
|
July 28, 1997: Matt Miller, 13-years-old from Overland Park,
Kansas, was given free samples of Zoloft by his psychiatrist. Seven days later, a day prior to
going on a much looked forward to vacation, Matt hung himself in his bedroom closet.
|
|
|
October 1st, 1997: Luke Woodham, a 16-year old in
Pearl Mississippi; Stabbed his mother, 50-year-old Mary Woodam, to death and then went to his high
school where he shot nine people — killing two teenage girls and wounding seven others. Published
reports say he was on Prozac.
|
|
|
December 1, 1997: Michael Carneal, a 14-year-old, Heath High
School in West Paducah, Kentucky; Opened fire on students at a high school prayer meeting. Three
teenagers were killed, five others were wounded, one of whom was paralyzed. Carneal was reportedly
on Ritalin.
|
|
|
March 24, 1998: Jonesboro, Arkansas; 11-year-old
Andrew Golden and 14-year-old Mitchell Johnson; Apparently, the boys faked a fire
alarm at Westside Middle School. When everyone came outside, the boys fired on them from the nearby
woods. They shot 15 people, killing four students, one teacher, and wounding 10 others. According
to one report, the boys were believed to be on Ritilan.
|
|
|
May 28, 1998: Encino, California: 40 year old Brynn
Hartman; Shot and killed her husband, actor Phil Hartman, as he slept. The following
morning she committed suicide. She was taking Zoloft. Reports say she had been complaining to
friends that she felt odd after taking Zoloft, which was given to her as a sample pack. Relatives
of the Hartmans released the following statement: "Phil and Brynn were a loving couple, devoted to
each other and their children. This tragedy is not indicative of who she was or who they were
together." According to the executor of Hartman's estate, Zoloft manufacturer (Pfizer Inc.) and
Brynn Hartman's psychiatrist, Arthur Sorosky, were at fault for Hartman's death. A wrongful death
suit was filed against them both. Pfizer settled the wrongful death case for an undisclosed
amount.
|
|
|
November 30, 1998: Dalton Township, MI: Seth
Privacky, 18-years-old; Shot his grandfather, parents, brother and brother’s girlfriend
while celebrating a late Thanksgiving. He was on Wellbutrin.
|
|
|
March 4, 1999: Marilyn Lemak, Naperville, Illinois; Lemak was
convicted of killing her three children, Nicholas, 7, Emily, 6 and Thomas, 3, by drugging the
children with a mixture of aspirin, Zoloft and the tranquilizer Ativan before smothering them with
her bare hands. Authorities said Lemak, a nurse, tried to kill herself with the same medication she
gave her children and then slashed her arm when her attempt to overdose failed. She was on Zoloft
and Ativan.
|
|
|
April 20, 1999: Columbine, Colorado; 18-year-old Eric
Harris had been taking an antidepressant when he killed twelve classmates, a teacher
and wounded 24 others before taking his own life in the bloodiest school massacre in history.
Toxicology reports confirmed that Luvox, an antidepressant, was in Harris’ system. He had
previously been on Zoloft. Dylan Klebold (17), Harris' accomplice in the
shootings, committed suicide immediately following the shootings of his classmates.
|
|
|
July 29, 1999: Atlanta, GA; Mark Barton 44;
On Tuesday, Barton went home and killed his wife. On Wednesday, he killed his two children. On
Thursday, Barton carried out Atlanta's worst mass murder when he opened fire with two pistols at
two different brokerage firms. In addition to the nine deaths at two Atlanta office buildings,
another 13 people were wounded. Barton, who had bludgeoned his wife and two young children to
death, killed himself in his van in an Atlanta suburb as police closed in on him. Prozac was later
found in the van.
|
|
|
August 10, 1999: Buford O'Neal Furrow Jr.; Los
Angeles, CA; Walked into the North Valley Jewish Community Center and, without a word, fired 70
rounds with a Uzi-type gun, wounding five people, 4 of them children. The day before he had shot
and killed a postal worker. Reported to have been court ordered to be on Prozac along with several
other medications.
|
|
|
September 15, 1999: Fort Worth, Texas; Larry
Ashbrook (47); At the Wedgwood Baptist Church, Ashbrook opened fire in the church
during a prayer meeting and killed four teenagers, three adults and wounded seven, before taking
his own life. He was taking Eli Lilly's Prozac.
|
|
|
November 22, 1999: Socorro Caro, 44; Northridge, California;
Socorro shot and killed three of her four children as they slept. She was angry after a fight with
her husband
and methodically shot the boys, Joey, 11, Michael, 8 and Christopher, 5 asleep in their beds with a
.38 caliber handgun. Caro then shot herself in the head in an attempted suicide, but survived. A
4th child, an infant, was unharmed. Caro was on Prozac and an anti-anxiety medication.
|
|
|
Jan. 5, 2000: Caitlin E. McIntosh, age 12; Died just 8 weeks after
being put on Paxil then Zoloft, of antidepressant-induced suicide. Caitlin was a straight “A”
student in 5th grade, a talented musician, artist and poet, who loved animals and wanted to be a
veterinarian. Then sixth grade began, and combined with the onset of puberty, this bright,
sensitive girl who had once loved going to school, was having trouble coping. She was also having
problems sleeping. Her parents wanted to help, so they took her to their family physician who gave
her Paxil. She didn’t do well at all on it, so he took her off - cold turkey. When they saw a
psychiatrist a week later, he put her on Zoloft. Caitlin hung herself with her shoelaces in the
girl’s bathroom at the Middle School she was attending. Her parent's said: "We were told that
antidepressants like Paxil and Zoloft were ‘wonder drugs’ and that they were safe and effective for
children. We were lied to."
|
|
|
June 3, 2000: Orem, Utah; Kevin Neil Rider, 14,
committed suicide while on Prozac. His mother writes: "Our doctor convinced me that Prozac was
right... Three months into his Prozac therapy I took my son back in to see if there was something
else we could try. My son didn't want to be on this drug. He claimed it made him feel 'weird'... I
asked [the doctor] what he knew about St. John's Wort, which I had heard helped with depression. He
was very much against any product that you could simply pick off any shelf in a regular
supermarket. He explained that St. John's Wort did not have any guarantee of safety, whereas Prozac
had been proven safe, and had FDA approval. He determined that what my son needed was a higher
dose, and promptly doubled it to 20 mg. per day." A few days later Kevin took his father's gun,
walked into a nearby orchard and shot himself in the head. Kevin's mother said, "I wish I had known
all that I do now about these drugs. Do you think I would have agreed to this drug if I had all of
the information? Of course not..." She has since become a strong anti-drugging advocate.
|
|
|
December 26, 2000: Wakefield MA; Michael
McDermott, 42; Shot and killed seven co-workers in a killing rampage at Edgewater
Technology where he was a software tester. Immediately after the shootings he waited patiently in
the lobby for arrest. Prozac, Paxil and Desyrel were found in his apartment. It's confirmed he was
on Prozac.
|
|
|
March 17, 2001: Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida; Leslie
Demeniuk, 31-yrs-old, killed her four-year-old twin sons James and John Demeniuk, they
were found shot in the head. The killings stunned those who knew the mother; they didn’t see it
coming. According to court records, Demeniuk’s Zoloft prescription was changed to Paxil two days
before the killings. Demeniuk had Paxil, remnants of Zoloft, alcohol and the anti-anxiety drug
Xanax in her blood during the night of the shooting.
|
|
|
June 20, 2001: Houston, Texas; Andrea Yates, 36
years old; Yates killed her five children — Noah 7, John 5, Luke 3, Paul 2 and Mary 6 months, by
drowning them in the bathtub. She had been treated with various drugs for post-partum depression,
including Wellbutrin, Effexor and Haldol.
|
|
|
November 28, 2001: Christopher Pittman, 12, Shot
and killed his grandparents while they slept, then set their house on fire and fled in the family
car. Pittman had been on Zoloft for one month and prior to that had been on Paxil.
|
|
|
January 25, 2002: Gainesville, FL; Tavares Eugene
Williams, 18, killed his guardian, Barbara Roth, 51, by hitting Roth three times with a
baseball bat. Williams was prescribed the anti-depressant drug Prozac about eight months prior to
the senseless attack.
|
|
|
July 18, 2002: Billy Willkomm, 19-years-old; Naples, FL.; Suicide.
An accomplished wrestler and University of Florida student, was prescribed Prozac at the age of 17.
He didn't get better. His family found him dead — hanging from a tall ladder at the family's
home.
|
|
|
August 31, 2002: Kelly Nakaji, Coeur D'Alene, Idaho; Smothered her
4 month-old son, Dallon with a pillow, then attempted to commit suicide. She was on Xanex.
|
|
|
November 2, 2002: Montville Township, Ohio; Dustin
Lynch, 15-yrs-old, had run away from home and was taken in by JoLynn Mishne, a 17-yr-old
girl and her family. One week later the girl was found at the home, beaten in the head with a
bedpost and stabbed with a kitchen knife, which was left protruding from her abdomen. Lynch was
taking Paxil.
|
|
|
June 25, 2003: Southbridge, MA; Diane Routhier,
40. Suicide. Diane had gone to the doctor for stomach pain and was put on Wellbutrin. Almost
immediately after taking one pill, she became violently ill so the doctors added an anti-psychotic
drug. Six days after taking her first pill, she went
to the bedroom, took the gun from the safe, went with it to the back right hand corner of the
basement, laid in a fetal position with the gun to her head and pulled the trigger, taking her
life. Her autopsy revealed she had gallstones, the real cause for her original symptoms. Why was
she put on antidepressants? Her husband, Allan and her two young sons are asking the same
question.
|
|
|
July 22, 2003: North Wales, Pennsylvania; Julie
Woodward, 17-years-old; A diagnostic test that she took at North Penn High School said
that Julie was suffering from depression. Two doctors at the clinic convinced her parents, Tom and
Kathy, to put her on Zoloft. Julie’s behavior actually got worse after only a few days on the
medication. And on the third day, Julie was arguing with her mother when she lost control and
pushed her to the floor - Everyone in the family was shocked because Julie had never pushed her
mother before. “It was an out-of-character act,” Tom Woodward said. And over the next few days,
Julie became extremely irritable and she could not sit still. Julie was usually very calm, but she
kept pacing incessantly. She also became reclusive. Six days after starting her treatment with
Zoloft, she hanged herself in her family's detached garage. Tom and Kathy are now activists and
work diligently to educate others about the risks of SSRIs with children. They have spoken at
hearings about the safety of SSRIs, including FDA hearings.
|
|
|
August 6, 2003: Tim "Woody" Witczak killed himself at age 37
soon after going on Pfizer's Zoloft — the top-selling member of Prozac's class of drugs, known as
selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, or SSRIs. His wife says Witczak was an upbeat man who was
prescribed Zoloft for job stress. "Woody's death was the most out-of-the-blue, out-of-character
death," Kimberley Witczak says. She has sued Pfizer, alleging that Zoloft induced the suicide, and
that the company failed to warn about the drug's potential to cause perilous side effects.
|
|
|
January, 2004: Candace Downing (age 12); Suicide; "Candace
was never depressed. She was a happy, beautiful child who had school anxiety," said Mathy Milling
Downing of Montgomery County, MD. Her 12-year-old daughter, who had been taking Zoloft, hanged
herself. "She was very into sports. A ton of friends, probably the most social child I've ever
met." The Downings, and other families, charge that drug makers knew from pre-marketing studies
that these drugs made some children and teens suicidal, but hid the study results.
|
|
|
February 7, 2004: Traci Johnson committed suicide while
enrolled in clinical trials of Eli Lilly’s Cymbalta. She hanged herself from a shower in the Eli
Lilly facility where the tests were being conducted. Cymbalta is the new “wonder drug” designed by
Eli Lilly to restore their flagging sales since Prozac ran out of patent. Traci Johnson was not
depressed prior to taking the drug. She was a normal happy girl who enrolled in the clinical trial
as a healthy volunteer in order to earn money to pay for her college tuition. Anyone with any signs
of depression was barred from the trials. Traci’s death, and the death of four other people at the
trial, were completely absent from the official records. The FDA backed this decision by Eli Lilly
saying that the deaths were a confidential part of the trial. The FDA states that the deaths of
people in drug trials COUNT AS A COMMERCIAL SECRET IN THE WORLD OF PHARMACEUTICAL COMPANIES.
|
|
|
June 12, 2004: Perry Custance, 22; Ruch, Oregon; Suicide; Perry
was prescribed the anti-depressant Lexapro after he sought treatment for a side ache and lower back
pain. Two months later he died of an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound.
|
|
|
November 22, 2004: Dena Schlosser, 35; Plano, Texas;
Schlosser cut off her 10-month-old daughter's arms as she lay in her crib in the family's
apartment. Her daughter, Maggie, bled to death. Schlosser had been prescribed two psychotropic
drugs and cycled on and off the anti-psychotic drug Haldol after Maggie's birth. Schlosser was
later diagnosed with a brain tumor.
|
|
|
March 22, 2005: Red Lake Minnesota: 16-year-old Jeff
Weise: Shot and killed his grandfather and his grandfather's companion. He then drove to
his school and shot the unarmed security guard, five students, a teacher and wounded seven other
students before turning a gun on himself. He was on 60 mg. of Prozac a day.
|
|
|
April 8, 2005: Rochester, NY; David Zacher,
35; Stands accused of stabbing his 34 yr old wife and 7 yr old daughter to death and critically
wounded his 2 year old daughter. Zacher allegedly told police that he was arguing with his wife
when she hit him on the head. The next thing he remembered was washing blood off himself in a
bathroom, he said. In his call to 911 he is allegedly heard to be shouting, "What did I do?".
Zacher had just been put on Paxil, an anti-depressant drug.
|
|
|
May 23, 2005: Fort Jennings, Ohio; Michael
Luebrecht, 38, called his wife at work and confessed to drowning their youngest son, Joel,
13 months old. Luebrecht was taking several drugs, including Zyprexa. Less than two months earlier
he had told his psychologist he'd had thoughts of killing his children, prompting his psychiatrist
to increase his dosages of Effexor and Wellbutrin.
|
|
|
January 20, 2006: Deerfield Creek, North Carolina; David
Lauren Crespi, 45-year-old senior vice president of auditing at Wachovia Bank, allegedly
stabbed his two 5-year-old twin daughters, Tessara Kate Crespi and Samantha Joy Crespi, to death.
Police say they found David Crespi outside of his home after calling 911 claiming he wanted to kill
himself. Neighbors in the affluent Deerfield Creek subdivision in Mathews, North Carolina were
shocked by the deaths saying the area is family friendly and that their kids routinely played with
Tessara and Samantha. Crespi had been taking Paxil, but it was causing him to gain weight, so he
was switched to Prozac.
|
|
|
June 30, 2006: Valeria Maxon, 32; Mansfield,
Texas; Maxon allegedly drowned her one-year-old son in a backyard hot tub. The boy’s father
returned home from grocery shopping to find his son Alex’s body in the hot tub in the backyard of
their home. Maxon was on Zoloft.
|
|
|
|